Enterprise vs SaaS Ecommerce
Magento vs Shopify — Real Cost Comparison
This is the widest cost gap of any platform matchup I cover. Magento 2 is open-source enterprise software you host, patch, and staff yourself — a store costs $15,000–$80,000 to build and $300–$600/month to keep running. Shopify is rented SaaS: $3,000–$25,000 to build, $39–$399/month plus apps, and someone else carries the infrastructure. I've scoped both for years — Magento work has been my day job since 2011 — and most merchants asking this question should hear an honest “you probably don't need Magento.”
Below: build cost, monthly running cost, and the full 3-year total for both platforms, using projectcostestimator.com's data from 600+ real projects.
Get Your Ecommerce EstimateQuick Answer
A Magento 2 store costs $15,000–$80,000 to build and $300–$600/month to run; Shopify costs $3,000–$25,000 to build and $39–$399/month plus $50–$200/month in apps. 3-year totals: Magento $40,000–$120,000, Shopify $12,000–$45,000. Magento developers bill $75–$150/hr and builds take 8–24 weeks; Shopify builds ship in 3–8 weeks. Scopebit’s engine applies a 2.0× multiplier to Magento and 0.85× to Shopify on identical scope. Magento earns its premium only for 1,000+ SKU catalogs, native B2B, or multi-store setups. Based on Scopebit’s analysis of 600+ real projects.
At-a-Glance Comparison
Magento 2 (Open Source)
- Build cost$15,000 – $80,000
- Monthly run cost$300 – $600
- Dev hourly rate$75 – $150/hr
- Time to launch8 – 24 weeks
- 3-year total$40,000 – $120,000
Shopify
- Build cost$3,000 – $25,000
- Monthly platform$39 – $399
- Monthly apps$50 – $200
- Time to launch3 – 8 weeks
- 3-year total$12,000 – $45,000
3-Year Total Cost — Real Numbers
Comparing for a mid-size catalog store: 500–2,000 products, $500K–$1M/year revenue, standard integrations (ERP feed, email platform, reviews). Magento column assumes Open Source edition — Adobe Commerce adds a $22,000–$125,000/year license on top of everything below.
| Cost Category | Magento 2 | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Initial build (one-time) | $35,000 | $8,000 |
| Theme / frontend | $1,000 (Hyvä) – $15,000 custom | $0 – $400 |
| Hosting (3 yrs) | $7,200 – $18,000 | Included |
| Platform fee (3 yrs) | $0 (Open Source) | $1,404 – $14,364 |
| Extensions / apps (3 yrs) | $4,000 – $10,000 | $1,800 – $7,200 |
| Maintenance + security patches (3 yrs) | $9,000 – $21,600 | $1,800 – $3,600 |
| Domain + SSL (3 yrs) | $45 | $45 |
| 3-Year Total (typical) | $65,000 | $16,500 |
Typical-case midpoints. Magento maintenance is not optional — unpatched stores get card-skimmed. See the full Magento cost guide and Shopify cost guide for the line-item detail.
Pick Magento When…
- ✓Catalog is 1,000+ SKUs with configurable products, tiered pricing, or complex attribute logic
- ✓B2B is core: company accounts, negotiated price lists, requisition lists, quote-to-order workflows
- ✓You run multiple stores, brands, currencies, or country sites from one admin
- ✓You need full code and data ownership — custom checkout logic, ERP-driven pricing, no platform limits
- ✓You have (or can retain) a Magento team — this platform punishes stores that skip maintenance
Pick Shopify When…
- ✓You sell DTC with a catalog under 1,000 SKUs — the sweet spot for Shopify's data model
- ✓You want to launch in 3–8 weeks instead of 2–6 months
- ✓Nobody on your team wants to think about servers, patches, or PCI compliance
- ✓Budget is under $25K — a $15K Magento build cut to fit a small budget ends badly
- ✓Checkout conversion and app ecosystem matter more than back-office depth
My verdict
Shopify is the right answer for most stores — probably 8 out of 10 merchants comparing these two. The 3-year gap is $28,000–$75,000, and for a standard DTC catalog that money buys nothing you will actually use. I say this as someone who earns a living building Magento: recommending it to a 300-SKU store would be billing for complexity the business doesn't have.
Magento earns its cost when the requirements are genuinely enterprise-shaped: 1,000+ SKU catalogs with real attribute complexity, native B2B workflows, or multi-store operations. In those cases Shopify's alternative is Plus at $2,300+/month plus a stack of apps approximating what Magento ships built-in — and the math flips. Price both honestly against your actual requirements, not your five-year fantasy roadmap. See all platform comparisons or read the longer Magento vs Shopify deep-dive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Magento cheaper than Shopify?
No — Magento is more expensive in almost every scenario. A Magento 2 store costs $15,000–$80,000 to build versus $3,000–$25,000 for Shopify, and Magento runs $300–$600/month in hosting and maintenance versus Shopify’s $39–$399/month plan plus $50–$200/month in apps. Over 3 years a Magento store totals $40,000–$120,000 while an equivalent Shopify store totals $12,000–$45,000. Magento only wins on cost when its built-in features (B2B, multi-store, complex catalog rules) replace functionality Shopify would need Plus ($2,300+/mo) or heavy custom apps to match.
How much does a Magento 2 store cost to build in 2026?
A Magento 2 (Open Source) store costs $15,000–$40,000 for a standard build and $40,000–$80,000+ for multi-store, B2B, or heavily customized catalogs. Magento developers bill $75–$150/hr and builds run 8–24 weeks. Add extension licenses ($3,000–$10,000 for a typical Amasty/Mageworx stack) and $300–$600/month for hosting plus security patching. Adobe Commerce (the paid edition) adds a $22,000–$125,000/year license on top.
When is Magento worth the extra cost over Shopify?
Three cases justify Magento’s premium: (1) catalogs over 1,000 SKUs with complex attributes, tiered pricing, or configurable products that strain Shopify’s variant limits; (2) B2B requirements — company accounts, negotiated price lists, quote workflows, credit limits — which Magento ships natively and Shopify only approaches on Plus; (3) multi-store operations running several brands, currencies, or country storefronts from one admin and one codebase. If none of these apply, the $28,000–$75,000 you save with Shopify buys a lot of marketing.
What do Magento and Shopify cost per month to run?
Magento 2 runs $300–$600/month for a typical mid-size store: $80–$500/month hosting (dedicated infrastructure or a small cloud cluster) plus ongoing maintenance and security patching, which is mandatory — unpatched Magento stores are a top target for card-skimming attacks. Shopify runs $39–$399/month for the platform (Basic to Advanced) plus $50–$200/month in app subscriptions, with hosting, security, and PCI compliance bundled in.
Can I migrate from Magento to Shopify to cut costs?
Yes, and it is one of the most common replatforming moves in 2026. A Magento-to-Shopify migration costs $5,000–$25,000 depending on catalog size, custom feature parity, and URL redirect work. Stores under 1,000 SKUs without B2B needs typically recover the migration cost within 12–24 months from the $250–$450/month running-cost difference alone. Stores that depend on Magento’s B2B or multi-store features should price Shopify Plus ($2,300+/mo) honestly before deciding — the savings can evaporate.
Price your store on both platforms
Enter your catalog size, features, and region once — get Magento and Shopify estimates side by side.
Compare My Store Cost